LOVE Island favourite Toby Aromolaran is in advanced talks to return to the villa for a third time.
Bosses are keen to sign up the footballer as a bombshell for this series of All Stars after his successful past two stints.
He met Chloe Burrows the first time round[/caption]
The second time he was with Georgia Steel[/caption]
A source told us: “Love Island bosses have approached Toby about coming back for another round in the villa.
“He created a lot of drama last time around with his turbulent romance with Georgia Steel, and obviously he was a fan favourite with his romance with Chloe Burrows during his original stint.
“Toby is weighing up the offer and he’s definitely tempted. The discussions are ongoing, and have been for a while, so don’t be surprised to see him returning as a bombshell any day now.”
Toby would not be the only star to return so many times – this series has already seen Casey O’Gorman hoping to be third time lucky.
He ended up in fourth place during the last series of All Stars with Georgia Steel but the pair split shortly after leaving.
The former couple faced intense scrutiny from fans and the cast of All Stars when they entered the villa
Just five months prior, they had filmed another Love Island spin-off, The Games, in Fiji.
People questioned their romance in the All Stars villa and whether they were faking it to win.
They initially had a spark on Love Island Games, but it fizzled out.
Georgia and Toby then signed up to All Stars and their history rippled through the villa.
Toby later admitted he had a tough time on the show and wanted to leave a number of times.
Chatting on a Reddit podcast, Toby said: “The first time (I was on Love Island) I never said I was going to leave – except from once.
“But this time, there was like five times I was like ‘I’m going to go’,” he explained.
He joked about how when Kaz left, he told Georgia to “pack her things” because they were “leaving”.
Toby and Georgia had a tough time last series[/caption]
Toby is said to be considering his options[/caption]
The pair discussed the PDAs and Toby admitted: “I think that was the worst day for me. I did leave.”
“You disappeared for like two hours, we were all sat there waiting to finish the PDA awards,” Kaz said.
Toby admitted: “That was actually really bad you know, you guys were trying to calm me down. No one was even looking at me in the eyes, it was mad.”
The Sun has approached ITV for comment.
Love Island All Stars 2025 official line-up
Love Island All Stars is back on TV for season 2.
Here we take you through the line-up of all the Islanders who are in the villa so far.
- Scott Thomas – season 2 (2016).
- Marcel Somerville – season 3 (2017).
- India Reynolds – season 2 (2017).
- Gabby Allen – season 3 (2017).
- Elma Pazar – season 5 (2019) – born in 1993.
- Curtis Pritchard – season 5 (2019).
- Kaz Crossley – season 5 (2019).
- Olivia Hawkins – season 10 (2023).
- Nas Majeed – season 6 (2020).
- Luca Bish – season 8 (2022).
- Catherine Agbaje – season 10 (2023).
- Ronnie Vint – season 11 (2024).
Bombshells
Each series brings with it a string of hot single bombshells making their epic entrance into the villa.
Here’s who has joined the villa so far:
- Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu – season 8 (2022).
- Casey O’Gorman – season 9 (2023) and All Stars (2024).
- Ron Hall – season 9 (2023).
- Tina Stinnes – season 2 (2016).
